The test is not inconvenience
Every disqualification is inconvenient. Losing your licence makes work harder, family life more difficult, and everything else slower. None of this is exceptional because it is true of every driver who is banned.
What the court is looking for is hardship that goes beyond the ordinary consequences of losing a driver's licence. The clearest way to demonstrate exceptional hardship is to show the effect on people other than yourself.
Hardship to other people carries the most weight
Arguments that succeed tend to involve consequences for third parties: employees who would lose their jobs if the business could not operate, a dependant relative who relies on you for care and transport, or clients in remote areas who couldn't be reached another way.
An argument built only on the effect on your hardship is much weaker, even where that effect is genuinely serious.
Losing your job is not, by itself, enough
Courts hear that a driver will lose their job in a large proportion of these applications. Standing alone, it rarely persuades.
What can persuade is what follows from it — that the mortgage can't be paid and the family would lose their home, that a business would close and other people would be put out of work, or that a specific care arrangement would collapse.
Bring evidence, not assertions
This is where most applications come apart. The court is being asked to depart from a mandatory penalty, and it expects to be given a proper basis for doing so. You are required to prove exceptional hardship in the balance of probabilities. Therefore, the following examples of evidence would help support your application:
- Employment contracts, payslips and correspondence from your employer
- Business accounts, and evidence of what the business does and who it employs
- Medical evidence where a dependant's health or care needs are relied upon
- Statements from the people affected — and, where possible, their attendance at court
- Evidence about public transport, taxis or other drivers, and why they would not solve the problem
You will be asked questions
You will usually give evidence yourself under oath. You can expect to be challenged on whether the hardship is really exceptional and whether there is another way around it.
Preparation is key to presenting an exceptional hardship case. When you know which questions are coming, you're far more likely to provide the complete picture to the court.
You generally get one go
Where the court accepts an exceptional hardship argument, the same circumstances cannot usually be relied upon again within the following three years.
That is worth knowing before the argument is run, because it affects whether this is the right occasion to run it. For example, if you have more speeding offences in the pipeline, you will want to wait until all matters are before the court before making the exceptional hardship application.
This article is general information about the law in England and Wales. It is not legal advice and it does not take account of your circumstances. If you are facing a charge or an investigation, speak to a solicitor about your own case.
Read more about exceptional hardship